Skip to content

The Future of Music Is Older Than You Think

It has been four years since my last post, and more than a decade since I first started this blog. I never intended to step away for quite so long, but I can at least say that the time did not go to waste.

A great deal has happened since I last wrote here. We lived through a global pandemic that silenced concert halls and rehearsal rooms around the world. Artificial intelligence went from a science-fiction premise to something many of us now carry around in our pockets. My own career changed shape several times. I went from working as a full-time freelancer, to teaching part time as a college professor, and now to teaching full time. I developed my psychoacoustics research, and presented it in France. Along the way I have taught what must be tens of thousands of lessons, classes, and masterclasses, run a low brass workshop, written a great deal of music, and performed many recitals and concerts on both trombone and piano.

I began this blog years ago as an attempt to challenge conventional ideas in music education with critical thinking and wisdom from other fields. As my schedule filled up, this pursuit got away from me. However, I wanted to begin again with a topic that has been on my mind for quite a while.

Years ago I wrote about something a professor of mine once told me: the tides of history always seem to wash everything along with them (see Music Education in the Information Age). Over the past several years we have been washed by several of those tides in quick succession. It would be easy to conclude that everything we once knew about learning, teaching, and making music now needs to be reinvented. I would like to argue nearly the opposite. The faster the world around us changes, the more valuable the things that do not change become.

A Lot Has Changed

When I wrote about music education in the information age in 2014, I predicted that video lessons, as frustrating as they were at the time, would steadily improve and eventually play a real role in how music is taught. I did not imagine that a pandemic would force nearly every music teacher on the planet to test that prediction within the span of a single week. Many of us learned to teach through laptop microphones and lagging video feeds. Ensembles disappeared for months. Teachers improvised with whatever tools they had, and many students went a long time without making music with anyone else in the same room.

Then came artificial intelligence. Software can now transcribe a recording, generate an accompaniment, analyze intonation and rhythm, write practice exercises, and even compose music of its own. Some of my colleagues find this thrilling, and others find it terrifying. Most of us, I suspect, feel a little of both.

Careers have changed as well. In 2016 I wrote that musicians should not expect all of their income to come from one place, nor expect to work the same job for their entire lives. That advice turned out to describe my own path more accurately than I expected. Very few musicians I know have followed a straight line from graduation to a single permanent position, and I do not expect that to become more common for the students graduating today.

What Hasn’t Changed

In the midst of all this change, I have been struck by how little the fundamentals of learning music have moved. Our students carry more computing power in their pockets than existed in the entire world a few generations ago. However, they are still endowed with the same brains and bodies as their ancestors. Learning still happens at the speed of the human nervous system.

A skill is still built through many correct repetitions, not through hours logged or information consumed. A musician still needs a clear aural image of how they want to sound before any exercise becomes meaningful. Our attention is still finite, and how we spend it still determines what we notice and what we improve. The words a teacher chooses still shape what a student does, sometimes for years afterward. And advice of every kind, no matter how impressive its source, still needs to be tested before it is trusted.

None of these fundamentals is really about music alone. Learning an instrument teaches us how to learn: how to break a complex task into manageable pieces, how to practice deliberately, and how to stay patient when progress comes slowly. Performing teaches us to manage our attention and our nerves when the stakes are high. Lessons teach us to receive criticism without being crushed by it. Ensembles teach us when to lead, when to follow, and how to listen closely to the people around us. These are meta skills, and they serve people just as well in operating rooms, courtrooms, laboratories, classrooms, and boardrooms. In a world where the specific demands of almost any job can change within a decade, the ability to learn well may be the most durable skill of all.

The technology surrounding music changes every year. The way human beings hear, listen, and make sense of sound does not. Whatever else the future holds, music will still be made for human ears and understood by human minds. That is the foundation on which everything else rests.

So what does this mean in practice? I would like to offer four ideas, each aimed at a slightly different group of readers.

Four Ideas for the Years Ahead

1) Artificial intelligence is the newest teacher in the room. Years ago I wrote that every piece of advice we receive is really a theory to be tested (see How to Know Who’s Right). It does not matter whether the advice comes from a famous teacher or an inexperienced student. All that matters is whether it actually works. I believe artificial intelligence deserves exactly the same treatment. It is simply the newest teacher in the room, and like every teacher it is sometimes brilliant, sometimes mistaken, and often confidently both at once.

Used well, these tools can be remarkable practice aids. When I recorded my first album, I spent weeks building narrated click tracks and MIDI drones by hand just so I could rehearse with myself. Today a student can generate an accompaniment, a drone, or a tempo map in minutes. That is a wonderful development, and I encourage my students to experiment with it.

The danger lies in letting the tool do our listening for us. A tuning app can tell a trombonist that a note is eight cents sharp. It cannot tell them whether that note ought to sit a little lower to lock into the chord their section is playing, or a little higher to lead more convincingly into the next phrase. That judgment belongs to the musician, and it develops only through careful listening. Software can suggest a fingering, an interpretation, or even an entire composition. It cannot decide how you want to sound. If we hand over our musical judgment, we have not saved ourselves any effort. We have only skipped the part of practicing that actually makes us better.

2) Live music is becoming the rare thing. Economists have long observed that abundance makes things cheap and scarcity makes them valuable. Recorded music has been abundant for decades, and artificial intelligence now threatens to make it practically infinite. When anyone can generate an hour of competent background music in seconds, competent background music will not be worth very much.

What cannot be copied is the experience of being in the room while music is made: the shared breath before an ensemble’s entrance, the energy of an audience, a teacher listening closely to a student and responding in the moment. The pandemic taught many of us this lesson the hard way. What we missed most during those years was not access to music. We had more of that than ever. What we missed was making music together.

For K-12 and collegiate teachers, I think this should change how we describe what we do. An ensemble is not merely a system for producing concerts, and a lesson is not merely a way to deliver information. The experience itself is the point, and it is becoming more valuable, not less. We should say so often to our administrators, our communities, and our students.

This value is not reserved for professionals. A community band, a church choir, or a few friends reading chamber music on a Sunday afternoon offers exactly the kind of experience no algorithm can replace. I do not believe everyone should become a professional musician, and many of my students should not. However, I firmly believe that anyone with an interest in music should feel free to pursue it unapologetically, at whatever level and for as long as it enriches their life. We rarely ask people to justify reading novels or playing basketball in terms of career outcomes. Music deserves the same respect.

3) Nobody assigns your practice anymore. This one is for my students who are graduating or have recently graduated. School provides an enormous amount of structure: weekly lessons, ensemble rehearsals, juries, recitals, and deadlines. Someone is always expecting something from you. Then you graduate, and almost overnight all of that structure disappears.

At first this freedom feels like a well-earned vacation. Then weeks become months, and many young musicians stop growing without ever deciding to. No one tells you that your practicing has drifted. No one notices that your sight-reading is getting rusty or that you have not learned a new piece in a year.

The solution is to become your own teacher. Set goals for yourself the way a good teacher would. Record yourself regularly and listen critically, both right away and again a few days later. Seek out feedback from colleagues you respect. Keep a running list of things you want to learn, and work through it. Some of the most important learning of my own life happened after I finished my degrees. My first solo recording, for example, taught me more about the recording process than any class I ever took. School is never really over. It simply stops being assigned.

This is just as true for those leaving school for careers outside of music. The engineering major who played in the university orchestra and the nursing student who sang in the choir will not have anyone assigning their practice either. Keep playing anyway. Join a community ensemble, take an occasional lesson, or read through duets with a friend. Music does not need to be your profession to remain part of who you are.

4) The portfolio career is not plan B. When I suggested in 2016 that musicians would increasingly rely on several sources of income, it still read like a warning. Today it is simply how most musicians I know make a living. For many years my own career was a combination of performing, private teaching, composing, recording, and part-time college teaching. Even now in a full-time position, I still perform, compose, and pursue my research. My sense of musical identity is far bigger than any individual job I will ever have.

What I have learned is that these activities are not distractions from one another. They reinforce each other. My research has changed how I teach. My teaching has changed how I practice. My composing has changed how I hear the music I perform. A career built from several related pursuits is not a consolation prize for those who could not land a single perfect job. In many ways it is more resilient, more interesting, and better suited to a world that will keep changing.

The same principle applies to careers outside of music. A physician who plays in a community orchestra, or a software engineer who composes in the evenings, is not leading a double life. Their musical training shapes how they think, collaborate, and solve problems at work, and their work in turn shapes how they make music.

For students, this means developing a broad base of skills while you are still in school. Learn to teach well, not as a backup plan but as a craft in its own right. Learn to record yourself and to communicate clearly about what you do. Say yes to opportunities that stretch you in new directions. You may be surprised where they lead.

Looking Ahead

So what can readers expect from this blog going forward? I plan to write about many of the same topics I always have: practicing, teaching, brass and piano playing, and the science of how we hear. I also plan to write more about the questions facing musicians right now, including technology, careers, and the future of music. I cannot promise a regular schedule, but I intend to write whenever I think I have something worth saying.

The tides of history will keep coming, and they will keep washing everything along with them. The fundamentals are what keep us afloat. The future of music, it turns out, is much older than we think. It is good to be back. Happy practicing and studying!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.